Should you get an aluminum boat or fiberglass? Skiff or Jon Boat? Flat bottom or V-hull?
These are all common questions when it comes to acquiring a small craft vessel…
In this article, we’ll investigate two of the most popular choices: The Carolina Skiff vs Jon Boat.
We’ll cover the physical characteristics, intended purposes, pros and cons of each, and other dividing factors.
Table of Contents
- Carolina Skiff vs Jon Boat
- Carolina Skiff vs Jon Boat: Pros And Cons
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Related Posts
Carolina Skiff vs Jon Boat
Although there are differences, these two boats provide similar versatility of use. The 16-foot variety of each provides a similar ride, with the skiff providing more comfort and features than the standard Jon Boat.
Carolina skiffs and Jon boats come in a variety of models, for this review, we will be comparing the JVX16 Carolina Skiff against a standard 16-foot aluminum Jon Boat.
Physical Comparison
To compare the JV16 Carolina Skiff to a standard Jon boat, we’ll begin with the outward most feature…physical appearance.
So, how does each boat look?
The Carolina Skiff JV16 is a small-sized, relatively flat-bottomed boat (they have slightly more of a V-shaped hull than a Jon Boat). T
These boats have a center console for steering, a skippers seat, a seat in front of the console, and space for passengers on the bow.
The Jon Boat lacks the center console, and the skipper steers the vessel from the outboard motor. The rest of the boat has benches leading to its bow. Jon Boats are considerably more flat-bottomed than Carolina Skiffs.
The table below compares additional physical features of the Carolina Skiff and the Jon Boat.
| Physical Component | JV16 Carolina Skiff | Standard 16 ft Jon Boat |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 15ft 10in long 78in beam (width) 19in gunnel height 973lbs. | 16 ft long 78in beam (width) 16in gunnel height 640lbs. |
| Shape | Not completely flat, the JVx has a slight V-shaped hull | Fat bottomed, with a slight V |
| Transom height | 15 / 20 / 25in | 21in |
| Draft | 4 – 6in | 4 – 8in |
| Load/Capacity | 1652lbs. 6 people | 900-1100lbs. 4-5 people |
| Mode of propulsion | Outboard motor | Outboard motor |
| Maximum speed | 25 to 30mph | Up to 35mph |
| Maximum Horsepower | 60 | 30 to 40 |
| Fuel tank | 13 gallons | Custom |
| Materials used | Fiberglass hull Stainless steel railings and steering wheel | Mostly aluminum, but some are fiberglass or polyethylene |
| Cost | Discontinued (manufactured from 2010 until 2017) Second-hand: From $8,900 | From $ 3,000 (new and second-hand) |
Features Comparison
The significant physical differences between a Carolina Skiff and a Jon Boat are that the Jon boat is simple and practical in build. There is very little “fluff” on these boats.
The Carolina skiff provides slightly more features with its center console, padded seats, and general look and feel.
Although these boats are sizably comparable, the Jon boat has a slightly flatter hull. The JVx 16, however, supports a marginally larger motor and one to two additional people.
While the JVx 16 was solely produced by Carolina Skiff, Jon Boats are a boat that many companies produce.
Some manufacturers and models include:
- Alumacraft 16ft
- Lowe L1648
- Smoker Craft 160 Freedom SC
- Tracker Grizzly 1648
- XPress Boats 1650 VJ
It is important to note that the JVx 16 Carolina Skiff is no longer manufactured. Carolina Skiff instead manufactures the 162 JLS, a comparable but updated model.
Where Jon Boats truly shine is their cost. They are much more affordable than the fancier skiff and are roughly half the cost of a JVx 16.
Aside from how they look and how they are made, the next important point of comparison is their purpose and where you can use these boats.
Intended Purpose & Uses
Carolina Skiff had fishing in mind when they designed the JVx 16. These skiffs aim to improve the shallow water fishing experience in style and comfort while providing conveniences.
Although intended for inshore fishing, the JVx 16 is a versatile craft with many uses, including:
- Saltwater fishing
- Crabbing , oystering, etc.
- Other recreational activities like wakeboarding, tubing, water skiing, and cruising.
To sum it up, the Jon Boat is versatile and was built to be an all-purpose vessel. Jon Boats between 14 and 16 feet are considered great for utility work and water sports.
Jon Boats in this size category excel in the following recreational areas:
- Duck hunting
- Freshwater fishing
- Cruising (especially lakes, rivers & swamps)
Carolina Skiffs and Jon Boats fulfill similar niches in that they are both built for utility and versatility. The JVx 16’s are geared toward fishing but compete on even footing with the 16-foot Jon Boat in all other uses.
Carolina Skiff vs Jon Boat: Pros And Cons
In order to properly compare a Carolina Skiff to a Jon Boat, we will look into some of the pros and cons of each.
Carolina Skiff Pros
- Due to its slight V-shaped hull, the JVx 16 handles rougher waters slightly better than the standard flat-bottomed Jon Boat.
- Transom height options allow for various motor shaft lengths.
- These skiffs come equipped with seat cushions, making for a more comfortable ride.
- Instruments on the console allow you to monitor and fine-tune your boat’s ride.
- Most Carolina Skiff boats are self-bailing, which is a very nice safety feature.
- The handrails, lockable storage compartments, and windshield are a source of convenience.
- These skiffs support bigger motors, which equates to power.
Jon Boat Pros
- The Jon Boat is significantly cheaper.
- Many Jon Boats have storage compartments onboard.
- Although simple, Jon Boats don’t have unnecessary extras, making them more durable.
- The Jon Boat is significantly lighter than the Carolina Skiff, meaning less fuel is required to use the boat and transport the boat.
- A trolling motor (in calm situations) is sufficient to power these boats.
Carolina Skiff Cons
- Carolina skiffs are significantly more expensive than the Jon Boat.
- They are slightly heavier, which means you’ll burn more fuel.
- The center console takes up a significant amount of space in the middle of the boat.
Jon Boat Cons
- Jon Boats are less comfortable and convenient than the Carolina skiff.
- These boats are slightly smaller than the skiffs and accommodate fewer people.
- They support slightly smaller motors, so they have less power than the skiffs.
Although both the skiff and Jon Boat have shallow drafts, the critical limiting factor would be your trolling motor and the boat’s intended purpose (i.e., fish of a decent size won’t be in such shallow water).
Frequently Asked Questions
If you still have some questions about Carolina Skiffs and Jon Boats, check out the FAQs below.
Which Is Better? A Carolina Skiff Or A Jon Boat?
The JVx 16 Carolina Skiff and the 16-foot Jon Boat are incredibly similar.
Personal preference and comfort aside, the most significant factor is the price. The Jon Boat is much cheaper, making it a popular choice for first-time boat owners.
They will, however, handle differently in certain weather conditions (the skiff’s slightly greater V hull provides better movement in rougher conditions).
The skiff, however, has more comfort and convenience, so the choice is yours, comfort or price.
Is a Small Boat Worth It?
Class A boats (16 feet and less) are fantastic for inshore fishing, lakes, calm rivers, etc. These boats are ideal for smaller groups of people that want to relax, fish, or participate in casual recreational water sports.
Their diminutive size means they are easy to launch and transport when you’re alone or with fewer people.
You May Also Like: Buying A Used Carolina Skiff? Here’s What You Should Ask
Growing up in Florida, I’ve been surrounded by saltwater my entire life…and I love sharing my passion with others.
To learn more about why I started Saltwater Mecca, visit the ABOUT page.
Thank you for reading this article. Browse around & have some fun!
